Columns

Ask Dr. Dave

December 1, 2010
/ Print / Reprints /
ShareMore
/ Text Size+
Adhesives and sealants troubleshooting tips from Dr. Dave Dunn.

Question: We bond sheet molding compound (SMC) with a polyurethane adhesive, then test the bonded joint by lap shear or cross peel. With one particular substrate, we get 100% substrate failure (in our industry we call it fiber tear) at 500 psi of pull force. With a second substrate, we get 800 psi of pull force, but only 60-80% fiber tear or substrate failure.

Which is considered better and why? We use the same cross-sectional area, as well as the same testing and sample preparation method for both substrates. The only difference is the substrate, and our customer likes to see fiber tear.



Answer: This is a common question when people bond porous or fibrous materials, and, quite frankly, tearing or failing of the substrate is not necessarily relevant. One must remember that many high-strength adhesive joints comprise bonding very strong, non-porous materials such as metals or glass.

The only important thing in an adhesive joint is that it is designed to withstand the static and dynamic stresses caused by its environment. In any adhesive joint, you can get three points of failure. First, the substrate can fail; this frequently happens when bonding weak materials such as paper or thin thermoplastics. The fiber tear you refer to is an example of this. The second failure point is the so-called cohesive failure of the adhesive, which is usually reflected by adhesive being observed on both sides of the adhesive joint after failure. Third, you can get adhesive failure where the actual adhesion to the surface is the weakest part of the system. In this case, one observes a clean surface on one or both surfaces of the substrate.

I have no doubts that your system with 800 psi is the best scenario for this bonded joint. In fact, the 800 psi you observe on the second substrate shows that it is a stronger substrate than the first one.

Links

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Adhesives & Sealants Industry Magazine.

Recent Articles by Dave Dunn

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

ASI April 2014 Photo Gallery

Our April 2014 issue is now available!

Podcasts

ExxonMobil Tackifier Expansion

Dwight Tozer, vice president of ExxonMobil’s Adhesion Industry business, discusses the company’s latest tackifier expansion project with Editor-in-Chief Susan Sutton.

More Podcasts

Adhesives & Sealants Industry Magazine

ASI Sept 2014 cover

2014 September

Our September issue features articles focusing on high-tech applications and raw materials, as well as a preview of the ASC Fall Convention and Expo. Check it out today!

Table Of Contents Subscribe

THE ADHESIVES STORE

handbook-sealant-tech.gif
Handbook of Sealant Technology

The Handbook of Sealant Technology provides an in-depth examination of sealants, reviewing their historical developments and fundamentals, adhesion theories and properties, and today’s wide range of applications.

More Products

ASI 2014 Buyers GuideASI's Buyers' Guide

Annual purchasing resource for equipment used in the manufacture/formulation of adhesives, sealants, pressure sensitives, tapes and labels and for application of finished adhesives. 

Clear Seas Research

With access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

STAY CONNECTED

facebook_40px twitter_40  youtube_40pxlinkedin_40 google+ icon ASI 30px