Manufacturers Call for Rejection of UP-NS Merger Application

Certain American manufacturing groups are calling on the Surface Transportation Board (STB) to reject the proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger, warning that the harms of the merger outweigh its benefits. They caution that the deal would give an already dominant railroad even greater monopoly control over the nation’s freight rail network while leaving American manufacturers with fewer choices, higher costs, and greater service risks.
The Alliance for Chemical Distribution (ACD), American Chemistry Council (ACC), American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM), National Industrial Transportation League (NITL), and The Fertilizer Institute (TFI) filed joint comments with the STB.
Representing chemical, fertilizer, petroleum producers, and other major rail customers shipping numerous other commodities and finished goods that collectively amount to millions of carloads each year, ACD reports that the joint comments also give a voice to companies that may be reluctant to speak out individually. Jim Vena’s statement that Union Pacific could increase rates on merger opponents “by three or four extra percent to teach you a lesson” has heightened concerns about retaliation among rail customers.
According to the participating manufacturing groups, the comments show that, despite the higher standards established by the STB’s 2001 merger rules, the application fails to demonstrate that the transaction is in the public interest and offers no meaningful plan to increase rail-to-rail competition.
The manufacturing groups stated four points that are considered the bottom line for rail customers:
- The merger would choke off competition and leave manufacturers with fewer choices. It would extend one railroad’s control over nearly half of the nation’s rail and leave more manufacturers with nowhere else to turn.
- A bigger railroad won’t fix broken service. UP and NS promise a more seamless network, but putting more traffic under one railroad does not eliminate the switching, local-service and reliability problems manufacturers face today.
- The promised truck-to-rail boom doesn’t add up. Many of the shipments UP and NS say could move off highways simply lack the rail access and infrastructure needed to make that switch.
- The damage wouldn’t stop with UP and NS customers. The merger could disrupt traffic and costs across the broader rail network, threatening to increase costs and degrade service on all railroads, and result in higher prices and delays for all consumers.
- A bad merger cannot be fixed with promises and temporary concessions. UP and NS have the burden of proving their merger enhances competition and serves the public interest. It is not the job of the STB or rail customers to fix a fundamentally flawed deal.
“This may be a good deal for Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, but it’s a bad deal for American manufacturing,” said Chris Jahn, president and CEO of the American Chemistry Council. “In Texas, the heart of America’s petrochemical industry, nearly three-quarters of chemical rail traffic moving into and out of the state could be controlled by a single railroad. Manufacturers need more competition and more choices, not a coast-to-coast monopoly that will raise prices for manufacturers and consumers.”
"Every stakeholder voice matters in these proceedings,” said Eric R. Byer, president and CEO of Alliance for Chemical Distribution. "It is disappointing that UP is trying to intimidate and belittle shippers' legitimate concerns. We applaud STB’s commitment to a thorough and fair review of the merger, and we hope STB will consider the lack of transparency and retaliatory tactics UP has used throughout this process. The proposed merger would give one railroad enormous control over shipping rates, service terms, and access to critical parts of the rail network. UP and NS still haven't made a convincing case that the benefits outweigh the clear downsides for small businesses and consumers. The STB must outright reject this proposal.”
Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!



